Lawyers question Miles' believability in closing arguments

by: Brian Bowling, TribLIVE Updated:


PITTSBURGH - A Homewood man wants eight jurors to believe that he's the only person telling the truth in his federal civil right lawsuit against three police officers, the lawyer for one of the officers said in closing arguments Thursday.

“Everybody is wrong but Jordan (Miles),” James Wymard told the jury. “Everybody lied but Jordan.”

This article was written by Channel 11's news exchange partners at TribLIVE.

Miles, 22, claims that Pittsburgh police officers Michael Saldutte and David Sisak and then-Officer Richard Ewing lacked probable cause to stop him, didn't identify themselves and used excessive force during his Jan. 12, 2010, arrest on Tioga Street in Homewood.

The officers contend that Miles was acting suspiciously, ran when questioned and fought officers when they arrested him. They claim he suffered most of his injuries when Sisak tackled him through a hedge onto rocky ground.

Lawyers for the other officers and Miles are scheduled to make their closing arguments Thursday, before U.S. District Judge David Cercone gives the jurors a final set of instructions and the jury starts its deliberations.

Wymard told jurors that there's no doubt that Miles was between two houses when the Saldutte and Ewing first spotted him that night.

“What do you want them to do?” he asked. “Keep going? Get coffee and donuts?”

The officers had reason to stop and question Miles, he said. Miles was an honors student at Pittsburgh's school for Creative and Performing Arts.

Wymard said it's up to Miles to explain why he was between the houses, but a plausible explanation is that he hears and sees that officers slowly coming up the street in an unmarked car with tinted windows and thinks they're gang members.

“This is Homewood, the home of the drive-by, the home of the gangbangers,” he said.

Miles ducks between the houses hoping to avoid being seen and then comes out when it's safe, only to be confronted by police officers who want to know why he was “sneaking” around someone else's house in a high-crime area, Wymard said.

Miles panics and thinks that if he can get home to his mother, she can explain everything, he said.





Witness can't recall previous testimony in Miles case

Jordan Miles takes the stand, says he did nothing wrong

Supporters rally outside courthouse as Jordan Miles’ mother takes the stand

Police abuse trial focuses on victim's dreadlocks

Jordan Miles’ lawyer grills officer over bottle

Pa. jury begins hearing about black man's beating

Lawyers make opening statements in Jordan Miles lawsuit

Jordan Miles civil lawsuit reassigned to new judge

Jordan Miles gets second chance to convince jury that officers used excessive force

Jury reaches partial verdict in Jordan Miles beating case

Jury begins deliberating Jordan Miles civil rights lawsuit

Defense rests; jury expected to get Jordan Miles case Thursday

Neighbors talk about crushed hedges, blood while testifying in Jordan Miles case

Police chief testifying at trial of 3 Pittsburgh officers

Jordan Miles describes police beating while on stand during civil trial

Jordan Miles’ mother, grandmother testify in Pittsburgh police beating trial

Jury of 5 men, 3 women selected to hear Pittsburgh police beating trial

DA: no charges against police in CAPA student beating

Rally, march held in honor of beaten CAPA student

Family rejects settlement offer in Pittsburgh police beating case

Pittsburgh offers settlement in CAPA student's beating

Group protests student's beating in Pittsburgh

Officers in CAPA beating case to be reinstated

Neighbors march for justice for Jordan Miles