PITTSBURGH - The man convicted in the death of a former Slippery Rock football player will serve five to 15 years in prison, an Allegheny County judge ordered Wednesday.
In April, 23-year-old Isiah Smith was found guilty of involuntary manslaughter in the death of 24-year-old Zachary Sheridan.
Sheridan was shot following a drunken brawl outside The Original Hot Dog Shop in Oakland on Aug. 3.
Smith admitted to police that he shot Sheridan in the back when he surrendered about 17 hours later.
Sheridan’s family was outraged that Smith wasn’t found guilty of a more serious charge since surveillance video allegedly showed Smith firing the gun.
The judge defended the lesser charge saying both men were fighting before the shooting.
During the sentencing phase, several family members and friends provided impact statements for Smith and Sheridan.
Smith's family asked the judge for leniency; Sheridan's family asked for the maximum penalty of 10 to 20 years.
“Justice may lie somewhere in the middle -- or not,” Common Pleas President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning said.
He added that but for Smith's possession of a gun, Sheridan would not have died.
“There's no gun here, there's no death. Perhaps some injuries, perhaps some bruises, but no death,” Manning said.
Channel 11’s news exchange partners at TribLIVE contributed to this report.
- Judge finds man guilty of manslaughter in hot dog shop shooting
- Surveillane video released from deadly "O" shooting
- Man wanted in death of ex-SRU player turns self in
- Ex-SRU player killed in Oakland laid to rest
- DA, owner of "O" meet to discuss safety concerns
Man convicted in ex-SRU football player's death gets up to 15 years
Mother's photo of Boston Children's Hospital bill goes viral
Mom's photo of Boston Children's Hospital bill goes viral
Report: Admitted drug dealer caught in stolen car
Metro Atlanta man set to cash in on extremely rare baseball card