Right-to-die? Death with dignity? Catholic Church says no

Right-to-die? Death with dignity? Catholic Church says no

PITTSBURGH — A proposal to allow people to end their own lives legally in cases of terminal illness is sparking debate in Harrisburg.

On Tuesday, Bishop David Zubik told Channel 11's Alan Jennings that the Catholic Church is not in favor of the Death with Dignity Act.

“I’d be really distressed to see that happen because, you know, the reality of what we teach in the Catholic Church is the absolute respect for human life from the first moment of conception to the point of natural death,” Zubik said.

Content Continues Below

Over the last year, two Pennsylvania lawmakers have worked to drum up support for the act.

Sen. Daylin Leach said, “You can either die at home with your family, or die connected to tubes at 3 in the morning alone in a hospital.”

His counterpart, state Rep. Mark Rozzi, introduced House Bill 2548, an exact copy of Leach’s.

It’s not clear yet how much support they’re getting from colleagues, but the House bill could come up for a vote early next year.

Unlike Oregon, only requiring one doctor, the Pennsylvania law would require two doctors to sign off on end-of-life medicine.

“I call it the slippery slope because once you open the door, then you know God only knows where it’s going to go from there,” Zubik said.

The Vatican isn’t alone. The Pennsylvania Catholic Conference is fighting against both death with dignity bills, as well.

“I think the movement toward that practice of euthanasia is a very dangerous one because I think it tries to take in our hands, as human beings, what ultimately belongs to God,” Zubik said.

Right-to-die advocate's mom blasts Vatican remarks

PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) -- Brittany Maynard's mother is responding angrily to criticism from the Vatican of Maynard's decision to end her life early under an Oregon law written to let terminally ill patients die on their own terms.

Days after Maynard's Nov. 1 death at age 29, the Vatican's top bioethics official called her choice "reprehensible" and said physician-assisted suicide should be condemned.

Maynard's mother, Debbie Ziegler, issued a sharp written response Tuesday. She said the comments from Monsignor Ignacio Carrasco de Paula, head of the Pontifical Academy for Life, came as the family was grieving and "more than a slap in the face."

Her response was made through Compassion & Choices, an advocacy group that Maynard worked with in her last days.

Maynard suffered from terminal brain cancer and in the spring was given six months to live. She moved to Oregon from Northern California with her husband and parents because Oregon allows terminally ill patients to die using lethal medications prescribed by a doctor.

Maynard used her story to speak out for the right of the terminally ill to end their lives on their own terms. A media campaign by her and Compassion & Choices sparked a national conversation.

Pope Francis also has denounced the right-to-die movement, saying euthanasia is a sin against God and creation. Thinking of euthanasia as an act of dignity provides a "false sense of compassion," Francis said Saturday. He didn't refer specifically to Maynard's case.

Some religious groups and social conservatives, including the American Life League, have criticized Maynard's decision.

In the letter, Ziegler called her terminally ill daughter's decision to die a human rights issue. Maynard's family has since moved back to California.

"My twenty-nine-year-old daughter's choice to die gently rather than suffer physical and mental degradation and intense pain does not deserve to be labelled as reprehensible by strangers a continent away who do not know her or the particulars of her situation," Ziegler wrote.

Ziegler encouraged people to consider all the options when faced with an incurable, debilitating, painful disease.

"The 'culture of cure' has led to a fairy tale belief that doctors can always fix our problems," she wrote.

On Thursday, the day Maynard would have turned 30, Compassion & Choices plans to release a video she made before her death. The group also will call for expanded laws that allow the terminally ill to end their lives.

Five states allow patients to seek aid in dying: Oregon, Washington, Montana, Vermont and New Mexico.

Oregon was the first state to make it legal for a doctor to prescribe a life-ending drug to a terminally ill patient of sound mind who makes the request. The patient must swallow the drug without help; it is illegal for a doctor to administer it.

More than 750 people in Oregon had used the law to die as of Dec. 31, 2013. The median age of the deceased is 71. Only six were younger than 35.