Pennsylvania

Complaints about privacy follow switch to paper ballots

HARRISBURG, Pa. — (AP) — As many Pennsylvania counties adopting new hand-marked ballot voting systems, a persistent criticism is a perceived loss of privacy in polling places when filling them out and scanning them.

The criticism, raised again Wednesday by state lawmakers, has emerged repeatedly ahead of the presidential elections, after a two-year push by Gov. Tom Wolf to get counties to switch to paper-based voting systems as an election security bulwark against hacking.

Some lawmakers say they have heard from unhappy voters accustomed to electronic touchscreen voting machines that, in the past, had been screened off or arranged to allow voters to make selections unseen.

Now, other voters or poll workers may be able to see how someone voted while they are filling out their ballot or while they feed their ballot into an electronic scanner that reads it.

“I think we’re disenfranchising so many voters who don’t like the new system," Rep. Doyle Heffley, R-Carbon, told top state election officials at an Appropriations Committee hearing Wednesday. “It’s not a secret ballot. Other people can see how they vote.”

Rep. Rosemary Brown, R-Monroe, pressed Department of State officials to step up training and resources for county polling place workers to protect privacy.

Kathy Boockvar, Wolf's secretary of state, told Brown that counties can seek reimbursement from the state for purchasing curtains or other privacy systems, and that her agency wants to help train polling workers on privacy.

Boockvar's top election deputy, Jonathan Marks, said he found that, in talking to voters who filed complaints, the lack of privacy is connected to a polling place's layout.

Some problems can be solved by ensuring that voters have a sleeve or folder to hide their filled-out ballot when they walk it to the polling place's scanner, he said.

Other problems might be solved by changing the polling place layout to ensure voters aren't congregating in an area where voters fill out ballots, Marks said.

Some counties bought ballot-marking systems that read a code printed on a piece of paper that is supposed to correspond to a voter’s selections on a touchscreen.

Most counties — like Carbon and Monroe — selected a hand-marked paper ballot system, in which voters use pen on a paper ballot to fill in a circle next to the name of the candidate they are selecting. The scanner reads which circle was marked.

If you’re reading this in the WPXI News App, you can click the + in the top left corner to sign up for Decision 2020 alerts.

Forrest Lehman, the director of elections in Lycoming County, which also switched to paper from electronic touchscreen machines, said privacy is more difficult to protect with any paper ballot-based system.

Even if a county invests in privacy screens or curtains to hide voters when they fill out ballots, the complication of using the scanner may require help from a poll worker, Lehman said.

“I’m not sure how to resolve that discrepancy,” Lehman said. “It’s a case where the poll worker feels like they're in a bind either way, and I think anytime you have paper ballots, you're going to have interactions like that.”

Still, he said, most poll workers and voters aren't interested in how someone else is voting.

___

Follow Marc Levy on Twitter at www.twitter.com/timelywriter