Decision 2020

Judge: Manafort lied even after agreeing to cooperate with Russia probe

A federal judge in Washington ruled on Wednesday that former Trump campaign manager Paul Manafort – while he was cooperating with an investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election and any ties to the Trump campaign – intentionally made false statements to the FBI, Special Counsel, and a federal grand jury, as Judge Amy Berman Jackson ruled that prosecutors were no longer bound by their plea bargain agreement with Manafort, opening the door to a longer term in prison.

In her ruling, Judge Jackson found that of five allegations raised by Special Counsel Robert Mueller's office, the 'preponderance' of evidence in three of the areas of dispute showed that Manafort intentionally did not tell the truth.

“Therefore, the Office of Special Counsel is no longer bound by its obligations under the plea agreement, including its promise to support a reduction of the offense level in the calculation of the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines for acceptance of responsibility,” Jackson wrote in an order released on Wednesday evening.

Manafort is currently in jail, awaiting sentencing.

Specifically, the judge found that Manafort ‘made multiple false statements’ about ‘his interactions and communications’ with his associate Konstantin Kilimnik, a Russian political operative who had worked with Manafort on behalf of pro-Russian officials in Ukraine.

U.S. officials have long believed that Kilimnik has ties to Russian intelligence.

In heavily redacted documents submitted to the court in December, the Special Counsel’s office alleged that Manafort had not told the truth repeatedly about his interactions with Kilimnik.

A separate filing by Manafort's lawyers – which included botched redactions – revealed that one question was whether Manafort had given campaign polling data about the Presidential election to Kilimnik during the campaign.

Judge Jackson ruled against the Special Counsel in two of five areas where Manafort’s testimony was questioned, including one where she said that Manafort had not lied intentionally about “Kilimnik’s role in the obstruction of justice conspiracy.”

At this point, Manafort is scheduled for sentencing on March 13; but it’s not clear if that will change in the wake of these findings by the judge.