• Proposal to separate public, private school playoffs unveiled


    PITTSBURGH - A compromise bill was introduced Tuesday in Harrisburg that will affect public and private schools in Pennsylvania when it comes to sports. Public school administrators have claimed they're at a disadvantage because private schools can recruit players.

    Channel 11 News first brought you the story in July when some public schools met to propose separating playoffs and then again in July when schools, the PIAA and lawmakers met at Heinz Field. 

    If you want to receive BREAKING ALERTS, please download our WPXI News App.  You can also follow WPXI on Facebook and Twitter

    Then in February, we caught up with state Rep. Aaron Bernstine, who is working with legislators to negotiate a compromise between the two sides.


    Bernstine graduated from Union High School, a small school in New Castle. He says he knows the issue well and is looking at creating a separate playoff system for public and private schools while also loosening transfer rules for student-athletes.

    Public school administrators point to the results on the field and on the court for why things need to change. Over the last five years, two-thirds of the state champions in football and boys' and girls' basketball have come from private or charter schools. By contrast, those schools only make up 15 percent of the PIAA.

    Critics of the change point to a nearly half-century-old state law that PIAA administrators believe prevents separate playoff brackets for public and private schools. Now, some are questioning that interpretation.

    RELATED HEADLINE: Legislators looking at proposal to separate public, private school playoffs

    List of private schools in WPIAL:

    • Aquinas Academy – Gibsonia 
    • Beaver County Christian – Beaver Falls 
    • Bishop Canevin – Pittsburgh 
    • Central Catholic – Pittsburgh 
    • Eden Christian Academy – North Hills 
    • Ellis School – Pittsburgh 
    • Geibel Catholic – Connellsville 
    • Greensburg Central Catholic – Greensburg 
    • Imani Christian – Pittsburgh 
    • Lincoln Park – Midland 
    • Nazareth Prep Academy – Emsworth 
    • Neighborhood Academy – Pittsburgh 
    • North Catholic High School - Cranberry
    • Oakland Catholic – Pittsburgh 
    • Our Lady of the Sacred heart – Corapolis 
    • Propel Andrew Street – Munhall 
    • Quigley Catholic – Baden 
    • St. Joseph School – Natrona Heights 
    • Serra Catholic – McKeesport 
    • Seton Lasalle – Pittsburgh 
    • Sewickley Academy – Sewickley 
    • Shady Side Academy – Pittsburgh 
    • Summit Academy – Butler 
    • Trinity Christian – Pittsburgh 
    • Vincentian Academy – Pittsburgh 
    • Winchester Thurston School - Pittsburgh


    Next Up: